Prettyflour here on behalf of with the critique you requested.
For such a short poem, this packs a great punch. When I read it I feel... a profound senese of loneliness, and I think the length of the piece lends a lonely feel. As well as the question, Are you like me?
I am a big fan of an author who can say a lot with just a few words. You have certainly done so with this poem.
Overall, I think you've done a fantastic job. It makes me want to read more of your work!
This quatrain speaks an entire story really well. I'll give you credit for that. The reason why I put it in my fantasy collection was because I imagined it to be someone who has lived a life of their own free will, but are pushed down by circumstances beyond their control.
All in all, its a very good poem - it speaks out (in itself) about how people are simply manipulative and provocative just so that they could get their ends of the bargain, rather than be bothered about what the other person thinks.
I was wondering what you meant by the last line though - "Empty head and lonely heart" would (if I am taking this correctly) mean you are talking to the person per say. In that it is you describing their character.
Apart from that one particular change, the rest is good. Keep writing and keep posting.
The poem is actually more personal than I like to admit - it's more of a question to someone, anyone, asking 'are you like me? do you feel how I feel?' It's all a question - I am saying 'I am battle stained with bloody scars, I have a empty head and a lonely heart - do you know what that's like?'
... m'dear... I think you just hit gold with that question you asked.
think about it:
I'm battle stained with bloody scars - I have an empty head and a lonely heart; DO YOU KNOW WHAT THAT'S LIKE?!
While this work in itself is good and Its sad to know that its personal (I'm really sorry for what you had to go through) but... the question you just asked is much more stronger...
I don't know about you, but I feel it should be something you could save for your own self... Just for the record...
This brief poem is actually quite brilliant and says so much with so little. You definitely portray a feeling of sullen loneliness without going into excruciating trivial detail with the piece. I am left with nothing to critique here. Well done!
so lonely but beautifully capturing, I feel your broken heart. but believe me you are not alone broken hearted, there are alike 10 million broken hearted!!!!
Prettyflour here on behalf of
For such a short poem, this packs a great punch. When I read it I feel... a profound senese of loneliness, and I think the length of the piece lends a lonely feel. As well as the question, Are you like me?
I am a big fan of an author who can say a lot with just a few words. You have certainly done so with this poem.
Overall, I think you've done a fantastic job. It makes me want to read more of your work!
I'd be really happy if you did read some other work of mine *not hinting, not hinting*
This quatrain speaks an entire story really well. I'll give you credit for that. The reason why I put it in my fantasy collection was because I imagined it to be someone who has lived a life of their own free will, but are pushed down by circumstances beyond their control.
All in all, its a very good poem - it speaks out (in itself) about how people are simply manipulative and provocative just so that they could get their ends of the bargain, rather than be bothered about what the other person thinks.
I was wondering what you meant by the last line though - "Empty head and lonely heart" would (if I am taking this correctly) mean you are talking to the person per say. In that it is you describing their character.
Apart from that one particular change, the rest is good. Keep writing and keep posting.
The poem is actually more personal than I like to admit - it's more of a question to someone, anyone, asking 'are you like me? do you feel how I feel?'
It's all a question - I am saying 'I am battle stained with bloody scars, I have a empty head and a lonely heart - do you know what that's like?'
thank you again for your comment
think about it:
I'm battle stained with bloody scars -
I have an empty head and a lonely heart;
DO YOU KNOW WHAT THAT'S LIKE?!
While this work in itself is good and Its sad to know that its personal (I'm really sorry for what you had to go through) but... the question you just asked is much more stronger...
I don't know about you, but I feel it should be something you could save for your own self... Just for the record...
This brief poem is actually quite brilliant and says so much with so little. You definitely portray a feeling of sullen loneliness without going into excruciating trivial detail with the piece. I am left with nothing to critique here. Well done!